Updated: Aug 15, 2020
We had the distinct pleasure of conducting one of our first interviews for the ClariLegal Value Series with Russ Dempsey of AIG. Russ leads the legal team in AIG’s group retirement division, with a focus on financial services and retirement products. Russ is also highly involved with the Association for Corporate Counsel – in particular, the ACC Value Challenge, and a member of ACC’s Board of Directors. Russ’s team at AIG handles a wide variety of legal issues for his division, including contractual matters, dispute resolution, and regulatory compliance with the SEC, FINRA, IRS, Department of Labor, and analogous state agencies.
Turning to the primary question, we asked Russ what value meant to him personally, professionally, and within the scope of his work. Russ started off noting the question of value often caused attorneys to stumble, as lawyers often prefer to think in definitive terms while value often doesn’t involve neat, definitive concepts. One definition of value Russ had heard defined the concept as ‘level of quality in context of cost’ – Russ noted while cost can be measured, quality was far more difficult to ascertain. How legal professionals measured, managed, and thought of quality was key to understanding the concept of value, according to Russ, who stated his preference to have both qualitative and quantitative measures of legal services. Quantitatively, Russ noted he measures factors such as responsiveness, turn-around time, and volume, and qualitatively looked at complexity of the work, outcome, and client satisfaction
We were also interested in getting Russ’ view of how the value exchange was viewed and communicate across parties. First, we asked Russ about his view on how outside vendors perceived value. Russ believes the onus was on in-house counsel customers of legal service vendors to communicate the customers’ preferred or sought value to the vendor to ensure both vendor and customer were aligned on the concept of value. In terms of communicating value, Russ emphasized the importance of informing outside counsel about how the in-house counsel intends to evaluate outside counsel’s performance, and ideally these discussions should be conducted at the outset of the engagement to ensure alignment of objectives.
Russ noted those kinds of conversations often do not occur between outside counsel and corporate clients, although he believed the increasing complexity of the supply chain was opening the door to vendors focused on providing value and things were trending in the right direction. Russ hit on the trend of value-based fee arrangements, but noted “getting a fee structure in place…isn’t the hardest part” – instead, communication and managing the process was the critical aspect of the customer-vendor relationship.
We also asked Russ about communication of value internal to an organization. Russ noted how he tracks a variety of metrics, with results consistently communicated both to the company management as well as in the legal department so teams could evaluate their performance relative to themselves and to the entire department. Although Russ noted this level of communication fostered both competitiveness among the legal department as well as defensiveness on occasion, it also engendered constructive conversations to help team members better understand organizational goals and standards – as Russ puts it, “reporting creates transparency”.
Finally, we opened the floor to get Russ’ additional thoughts on value and the value exchange. Russ noted his work with the ACC’s Value Challenge, which was started after 2008 when in-house counsel were obligated by their CFOs and CEOs to do more legal work with fewer financial resources. The ACC Value Challenge runs an awards program (of which Russ is a recipient) celebrating those delivering value in the legal industry. Russ believes the Challenge facilitated and elevated the conversation around value in the legal industry, even 10 years in, by giving lawyers the business skills not taught in law school.
About Russ Dempsey
Russ Dempsey is a leader in creating greater value in legal services. Russ has several years of experience driving results for clients by increasing efficiency within the legal and compliance departments; by designing and implementing process improvement/project management initiatives; and, by structuring value-based relationships with outside counsel. Russ is currently Assistant General Counsel for AIG, where he leads a legal team that supports its Retirement business.
Russ is a frequent speaker on legal project management and value-based billing practices.
He has been named a Value Champion by the Association of Corporate Counsel (ACC) for creativity in driving value, efficiency and greater predictability in his role as in-house general counsel. Russ has served on the faculty for ACC’s Legal Services Management Workshop since 2014, and is currently a member of ACC’s Board of Directors, where he Chair of the Board’s Advocacy Committee. Russ is also a member of ACC’s Value Challenge Steering Committee.
Russ holds both a JD and an LL.M. in taxation. He received his BA in Philosophy from
Marshall University. Contact info: (713) 342-7421 – Russ.firstname.lastname@example.org
About the Authors James Johnson is principal attorney of First Venture Legal, a Cambridge, Massachusetts-based law practice focused on corporate and transactional law for very-early-stage startups. James assists entrepreneurs and small business owners with corporate formation and structuring, contracts, commercial law, employment matters, and early-stage fundraising. His practice utilizes alternative fee structures to deliver value-based service to early-stage ventures. In addition to practicing law, James works with ClariLegal, focusing on building out its innovative platform and spreading the word of ClariLegal’s mission to reduce cost and complexity in legal vendor selection and management for law firms and corporations.
Cash Butler is the founder of ClariLegal, a preferred Litigation/Legal vendor management platform that matches corporations and law firms with the right vendors who have the right service offering at the right price.
A seasoned legal technology innovator, Cash has over 18 years of experience in the legal vertical market, primarily working in eDiscovery, litigation & compliance. Cash is an expert in legal vendor, pricing and project management.